Friday, October 23, 2020
Home World Justices to weigh Trump census plan to exclude noncitizens

Justices to weigh Trump census plan to exclude noncitizens

Washington, Oct 17 : The Supreme Court agreed Friday to take up President Donald Trump’s policy, blocked by a lower court, to exclude people living in the U.S. illegally from the census count that will be used to allocate seats in the House of Representatives.

Never in U.S. history have immigrants been excluded from the population count that determines how House seats, and by extension Electoral College votes, are divided among the states, a three-judge federal count said in September when it held Trump’s policy illegal.

The justices put the case on a fast track, setting arguments for Nov. 30. A decision is expected by the end of the year or early in January, when Trump has to report census numbers to the House.

Trump’s high court nominee, Amy Coney Barrett, could take part in the case if, as seems likely, she is confirmed by then.

Last year, the court by a 5-4 vote barred Trump from adding a census question asking people about their citizenship. Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, who died last month, was part of that slim majority. Barrett would take Ginsburg’s seat.

Trump left it to Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross, who oversees the Census Bureau, to figure out how many immigrants are not living legally in each state.

The outcome of the census case could affect the distribution of political power for the next 10 years. The census also helps determine the distribution of $1.5 trillion in federal funding annually.

The administration told the court that the president retains “discretion to exclude illegal aliens from the apportionment based on their immigration status.” The American Civil Liberties Union, representing a coalition of immigrant advocacy groups, said Trump’s violation of federal law is “not particularly close or complicated.”

The Supreme Court separately allowed the administration to end the actual census count this week, blocking a court order that would have kept the count going until the end of the month.

The court did not take action on two other administration appeals of controversial policies on asylum seekers and the border wall that also were ruled illegal by lower courts.

Since early last year, the administration has made asylum-seekers wait in Mexico for U.S. court hearings, which has forced tens of thousands of people to return to Mexico.

Known informally as “Remain in Mexico,” the policy became a key pillar of the administration’s response to a surge of asylum-seeking families from Central America at the southern border. It also drew criticism for having people wait in dangerous cities.

The administration also is appealing a ruling that the administration can’t spend more than Congress authorized for border security. After Congress refused to give Trump all the money he wanted for the wall, he declared a national emergency at the border and Defense Department officials transferred billions of dollars to the project.

Lower courts sided with states and environmental groups that challenged the transfer as a violation of the Constitution’s provision giving Congress the power to determine spending. A separate suit from members of Congress also is making its way to the court.

The justices blocked the court rulings in both the asylum seekers and border wall cases, leaving the policies in effect. Arguments wouldn’t heard before next year and the issues would have much less significance if Joe Biden were to become president. He could rescind Trump’s policy forcing asylum seekers to wait in Mexico, for example.

SourcePTI

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

LATEST POST

Will reject central farm acts after SAD forms govt in Punjab: Sukhbir

Chandigarh, Oct 22 : SAD chief Sukhbir Singh Badal on Thursday said his party will not allow implementation of the Centre's farm laws when...

Adani to take over airport ops at Mangaluru by Oct 31, Lucknow by Nov 2, Ahmedabad by Nov 11: AAI

New Delhi, Oct 22 : The Adani group would be taking over the operations, management and development of the airports at Mangaluru, Lucknow and...

Rasika Dugal opens up about receiving ‘misogynistic’ comments for ‘Mirzapur’

Mumbai, Oct 22 : Actor Rasika Dugal on Thursday said every time she puts a post on social media about her character Beena Tripathi...

PM, Union ministers, CMs, political leaders greet Amit Shah on birthday

New Delhi, Oct 22 : Prime Minister Narendra Modi, Union ministers, chief ministers and leaders of different political parties on Thursday greeted Union Home...

MOST READ

IIT-Kharagpur develops low-cost, portable COVID-19 testing device

New Delhi, Oct 21 : The Indian Institute of Technology (IIT)-Kharagpur has developed a low-cost portable COVID-19 testing device that can deliver results within...

DU releases its second cut-off list

New Delhi, Oct 18: The Delhi University released its second cut-off list on Saturday, with many courses being closed for admissions and some programmes...

MP bypolls: Some govt officials supporting BJP, says Digvijaya

Bhopal, Oct 16 : Ahead of bypolls to 28 Assembly seats in Madhya Pradesh on November 3, senior Congress leader and Rajya Sabha MP...

SC to examine if educational institutions, varsities fall under consumer law

New Delhi, Oct 21 : The Supreme Court has agreed to examine the question as to whether an educational institution or university can be...